Chocolate Cream Pie Recipe: An Easy Homemade ClassicABy Ashton · Updated October 21, 20264.216 reviews·Total 25 min·Serves 8 slicesJump to Recipe Save Pin Add to Google posted by Ashton on October 20, 2026 Yesterday I made a buttermilk pie crust. Today, of course, I filled it with the best chocolate cream pie recipe I own, and you guys, I am not being dramatic when I say this might be my desert island dessert. 🏝️ Chocolate cream pie is quite possibly my favorite pie of all time, but I almost always forget about it unless someone else makes it. It gets eclipsed by the fancy stuff — pumpkin, pecan, even a chocolate chess pie — on holiday dinners. This is reason grandma’s chocolate pie never got its due at our table, honestly, and it’s the reason I’m fixing that right now with a good, old-fashioned, from-scratch version. When this pie does make it onto the table, I become a woman on a mission to eat a second helping and then some. Can we talk about how a flaky crust plus a fudgy filling plus a cloud of whipped cream is just… good things happening all at once? Why This Chocolate Cream Pie Recipe Is My Starting Point This is a 100% from-scratch chocolate pudding filling, no instant mixes here. I don’t mind a s-y cake mix or a pre-baked pie crust on a busy day, and I’m a happy user of instant pudding when life calls for it. But a homemade filling is extra thick, extra creamy, and extra chocolatey, with a smooth finish you just can’t fake. Whisk egg yolks into a large bowl with cups of sugar, a cup of cornstarch, and a pinch of salt, then slowly stir eggs in with warm chocolate milk so they don’t scramble. Pour in a ladleful of the hot filling at a time, add good chocolate and a couple tablespoons of butter, and a teaspoon vanilla extract for that warm, cozy finish. Prep time is short, but chill time is everything here. Make the crust, whisk the filling, pour, and let it set filling overnight so it slices clean instead of slumping. I still remember the sound of her wooden spoon scraping the pot when my grandma made hers, no semisweet chocolate chips or corn syrup shortcuts, just unsweetened cocoa and patience. That’s the different version I grew up on, and it’s still my go-to twists on a classic. A Few Favorite Potluck Recipes and Pie Cousins If chocolate cream pie had cousins, they’d be peanut butter chocolate pie, chocolate pecan pie recipe fans, and anyone obsessed with Kelly’s French Silk Chocolate Pie or an ice-cream pie for summer potlucks. I love browsing recipes breakfast through dessert on food blogs — mexican recipes one day, thai recipes the next, then italian recipes, indian recipes, chinese recipes, japanese recipes, korean recipes, and spanish recipes, because variety really is the spice of best dinner recipes. For my actual diet keto recipes days I stick to healthier swaps, but this pie is not that. This pie is a delicious meal finale, moist & delicious in every bite, pure sweet base and crackly top perfection. Tips, Twists, and a Little Extra Sass A meringue topping made from egg whites is a classic swap if whipped cream isn’t your thing, and both give the pie that crackly top finish people photograph for recipe photos before they even take a bite. My oldest son requests this for every birthday, including his 59th b’day joke (he’s nowhere near 59, but he loves the bit). I’ll admit the only drama in our house is deciding who gets the last sprinkle of cocoa powder on top and a pinch of cream in their coffee to go with it. If you’ve ever watched a tiktok – make video of someone slicing into a chocolate chess pie or chocolate pecan pie recipe and thought “I need that,” just make your own and skip the img src searching. I used to dig through old photobucket – video and photobucket image hosting photo sharing albums for pie inspiration — remember hunting for good quality pics like http://i23.photobucket.com/albums/b399/susied214/permanent%20collection/untitled.jpg”””” border or http://i23.photobucket.com/albums/b399/susied214/projects/200_pacpic.jpg”””” border back in the day? Simpler internet times, honestly, before related pages and top icons and giving up your personal information just to see a pie photo. These days a quick search for the best belgian waffles e or easy dinner ideas pulls up everything, no warner bros. discovery or discovery family channel required, and definitely no canadian military connection, I just like saying that out loud. Young Living diffuser going, pot recipes simmering, whole family gathers around for this pie, every single time. How to Serve Your Chocolate Cream Pie This pie is really easy to pull together: make the crust, whisk the filling, pour, and chill completely, overnight, so don’t skip that step! Then enjoy. Savor each creamy bite of that fudgy filling, and don’t feel obliged to share — pie tick that box for yourself first. If you love chocolate desserts like this, you’ll probably also love a chocolate trifle or a slice of black forest cake roll for your next holiday spread. And if anyone asks for the recipe, just hand them your email address and send it along — good things are meant to be shared, even if the pie itself isn’t. Homemade Chocolate Cream Pie Yield: 8 slices Prep Time: 10 minutes Cook Time: 15 minutes Total Time: 25 minutes Save this recipe for later: Save Pin Add to Google The most important part of making this pie is giving yourself enough time. It's needs to chill overnight. So be sure to make it the night before you want to eat it!! Print Ingredients 9-inch pie crust, pre-baked 3 egg yolks 3 cups milk 1 1/2 cups white sugar 3 tbsp cornstarch 1/2 cup unsweetened cocoa powder 1/2 tsp salt 1 tbsp butter 1 1/2 tsp vanilla extract whipped cream and chocolate shavings for toppings Instructions In a large saucepan (the heat is NOT on at this point), whisk together the egg yolks and the milk.In a medium bowl, mix together the sugar, corn starch, salt and cocoa powder.Whisk the dry ingredients into the wet ingredients in the sauce pan. Turn heat to medium-high. Whisk continually until mixture begins to thicken and bubble (about 10-15 minutes).Remove from heat and add the butter and vanilla. Mix well. Serve immediately warm, or pour into cups with lids and store in the refrigerator. Nutrition Information: Yield: 8 Serving Size: 1 Amount Per Serving: Calories: 364Total Fat: 11gSaturated Fat: 5gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 5gCholesterol: 81mgSodium: 299mgCarbohydrates: 60gFiber: 2gSugar: 39gProtein: 7g
I too, am a huge fan of chocolate cream pie, but never make it! This looks super silky and rich… I’ll have to try my hand at it!
I’m the same way-poor chocolate cream pie! So delicious and so often forgotten! Thanks for reminding me of the lusciousness that is Chocolate Cream Pie!
I love that you did a scratch pie (no coolwhip, no pudding mix – I love them both but like you, there’s a time and a place) and the results are stunning!!! The filling, omg. Perfection! Some of your most beautiful images, too! I can literally see the serrated knife/slice marks on the 3rd pic down! Gorgeous. Wish I was having some! Pinned 🙂
Thank you Averie!! It always means so much to me when you compliment my photography, because yours is so stunning!
Any type of Chocolate Pie is always, always my favorite! I love that there’s no pudding mix involved — and I’m sure that makes the taste especially phenomenal! 🙂 Can’t wait to try out the recipe!
I love the delicate little chocolate curls! I’m also in love with the fact that this doesn’t have any pudding mix. From scratch desserts are the best!
Just gorgeous! What a beautiful rich pie, I would love slice of this. I need to put this on my to-make list!
I know people hate when other people change their recipes but this was really calling my name. My husband is lactose intolerant and his mother is visiting who is on a total dairy free diet so I made a few changes but I’m pretty sure it worked out great! It is still cooling but it already thickened a ton and the filling tasted great! My husband tested it too. (I used coconut milk instead of milk and coconut oil instead of butter. So maybe I turned it into Chocolate-Coconut Cream Pie but I think it is going to hit the spot!) And it was super easy!
This sounds absolutely amazing! Just one question, should I cover the filling with plastic wrap while it cools so it doesn’t get a film like homemade pudding does? I can’t wait to try it on Thanksgiving!
I didn’t cover, and it was fine! The film must have been very thin, because it wasn’t noticeable at all after I covered it in whipped cream and ate it 🙂
This pie looks amazing. I used a store bought gluten free crust. I just hope mine turns out as good as this one. We will find out in the am. Now to see if my chocolate curls turn out as good as yours. Thanks for sharing!!
After following all the directions and putting the pie in the fridge, I realized the salt is nowhere in the directions. I hope it doesn’t taste bad.